American Augers April 2019 Print Issue Charles Machine Works Ditch Witch Features HammerHead Trenchless Mergers and Acquisitions Minnesota MTI Equipment New Installation Oklahoma Radius HDD Rehabilitation Subsite Electronics tech The Toro Company United States

Looking at the Toro Co. and Charles Machine Works Deal

The Toro Co.

Toro and Charles Machine Works Made Headlines in February with Their Announcement. What’s Subsequent?

In a move that caught the trenchless business abruptly, The Toro Co. introduced on Feb. 15 that it had acquired the long-lasting Charles Machine Works (CMW) and its household of trenchless corporations — that includes the pioneering Ditch Witch model — for $700 million.

Like a whirlwind, a press conference a number of days later at the American Rental Association (ARA) show had the leaders of both corporations — Toro’s Rick Olson and Charles Machine Works’ Rick Johnson — at the podium, explaining the business shake up that solidly positions the Toro Co. close to the top of trenchless world.

Along with the Ditch Witch brand, Toro additionally acquired the next trenchless brands beneath the CMW umbrella: HammerHead Trenchless, Radius HDD, Subsite Electronics, American Augers and MTI, as well as DMTXS in Beijing. CMW generated calendar yr 2018 revenues of approximately $725 million. Toro and Ditch Witch have competitive merchandise within the horizontal directional drilling (HDD) market, in addition to in trenching and compact device service categories.

RELATED: The Toro Firm to Acquire The Charles Machine Works Inc.

The acquisition was finalized on April 1.

Whereas the news might have blindsided the business and CMW staff, talks between the 2 development giants began more than two years in the past with an unsolicited, preliminary, non-binding supply from Toro.

“[CMW] was not for sale. The household had every intention of continuous possession,” says CMW and Ditch Witch CEO Rick Johnson. “There was not a necessity nor a want to promote the corporate. Nevertheless, we have been introduced with a big, viable supply from a very well-respected company. Though a gut-wrenching choice, it was one the [Malzahn] household felt they might not ignore.”

As soon as the deal is finalized, the Malzahn family will not be involved in CMW; Tiffany Sewell-Howard (granddaughter of founder Ed Malzahn) will resign as government chair and the board of directors might be dissolved. “The Malzahn household’s focus will shift towards stewardship of the Malzahn Household Affiliated Fund and its mission to help Perry, Oklahoma, and guarantee a robust group to help [Ed Malzahn’s] legacy and the way forward for Charles Machine Works,” Johnson stated.

Johnson noted that there was “a big quantity of shock” by the CMW staff at the announcement. “Although rumors come and go, there was an expectation that the Malzahn family would continue their ownership of Charles Machine Works,” he stated. “The enterprise case behind the choice is usually understood and accepted; nevertheless, change is troublesome and the emotional toll is great. There will probably be an adjustment period for all of us.”

RELATED: The Toro Co.: Painting the Underground Development Market Purple

For Toro’s half, the chance to advance additional into the highest echelon of the trenchless business has been a aim for some time — and this acquisition definitely aids within the execution of that aim. In 2013, the corporate dipped its toes into the trenchless market with the acquisition of Astec’s HDD smaller rig line. Although the corporate developed two of its personal compact and midsize rigs — its 22,000-lbs DD2226 and 40,000-lb DD4050 — it didn’t make a lot headway in gaining a trenchless leadership position within the business. Now, not solely has it added one among most recognizable HDD rig product fleets with Ditch Witch, but five other robust trenchless manufacturers, as well as entrance within the trenchless rehab market with HammerHead Trenchless and Subsite.

“[That] acquisition offered us entry into the underground development market and we’ve got discovered an ideal deal alongside the best way,” says Toro Group vice president-construction companies Rick Rodier. “We now higher perceive the dynamics of the market and have gained a greater understanding of how The Toro Co. can help Charles Machine Works imaginative and prescient of being the underground authority.”

With the addition of the Charles Machine Works household of corporations, The Toro Co. provides to its HDD
product line entrance into the rehab market by means of HammerHead Trenchless and Subsite Electronics.


Each corporations include rich, longstanding histories. Headquartered in Bloomington, Minnesota, the Toro Co. was founded in 1914 and is a leading worldwide provider of turf and landscape maintenance gear, rental and specialty development gear, snow and ice administration gear and irrigation and outside lighting options. Its supplier, distributor and retailer networks reach more than 125 nations.

Headquartered in Perry, Oklahoma, CMW designs, manufactures and sells a variety of products together with HDD gear, walk-behind and ride-on trenchers, compact device carriers, vacuum excavators, asset locators, pipe rehabilitation solutions and after-market tooling. The company’s roots date back to 1902 when it began as a blacksmith shop. Trenchless pioneer Ed Malzahn invented the service line trencher and launched an business, turning into The Charles Machine Works Inc. and manufacturing a comprehensive line of underground development gear, worldwide. CMW started adding trenchless corporations to its portfolio in 2010. Immediately, CMW has 170 Ditch Witch sellers promoting in 110 nations.

In December 2015, Malzahn passed away at age 94. The corporate reins had already been turned over to Sewell-Howard in 2003. His dying might have triggered The Toro Co. to provoke the conversation with CMW about selling, nevertheless it was not a factor within the board of directors’ and family’s choice to sell, Johnson stated.

“Ed Malzahn had a robust appreciation for many who supported him in his journey: the Perry group, the workers of Charles Machine Works, the Ditch Witch vendor organization, and his family…in that order. As a consequence of Ed’s priorities, the family strongly believes Ed would have accepted the supply from The Toro Firm. By selling the company the household feels they’re honoring Ed’s legacy,” Johnson stated. “A large portion of proceeds from the sale of the corporate will go toward the Malzahn Family Affiliated Fund which advantages the group of Perry, Oklahoma. These dollars can be used for group improvement that may ensure Perry will thrive and help the expansion of the Firm into the longer term.”

RELATED: All the Right Strikes: Charles Machine Works Expands Its Trenchless Market

CMW is Perry, Oklahoma, and the considered having its operations moved from the town that employs so many played an element in the negotiations. Johnson noted that there were a number of non-negotiables discussed through the process, corresponding to sustaining operations in Perry and making certain worker members of the ESOP get the same payout as all different shareholders, as well as persevering with to spend money on CMW’s market-leading manufacturers.

“We stay committed to the communities where Charles Machine Works staff stay and work … We very a lot worth the wealthy history and connection that Charles Machine Works has inside the Perry group and plan to proceed to build upon that power,” Rodier stated. “Operations will stay in Perry. Actually, the Perry location will grow to be Toro’s largest manufacturing facility worldwide.”

On the ARA press convention, Olson stated this: “Our intention is to manage the Ditch Witch brand and all of the brands of both Charles Machine Works with the Toro brand. It is going to be a twin brand technique. So, there isn’t any intention of taking present fashions away or making a mannequin that’s at present orange pink. That’s not to say someday down the street … If there are opportunities to help one of many companies grow or get into an space that that makes good business sense, we might discover that. However there’s definitely not our intention at this time.”

american augers hdd rig

The Toro Co. acquisition of Charles Machine Works consists of American Augers.

The Future

What’s the short-term and long-term impression of this deal? Both corporations have robust supplier networks strung out around the globe. For them, will probably be business as typical, Rodier stated. “One of the things that makes Charles Machine Works and its household of corporations so successful is its robust supplier channel,” he stated. “It was a key purpose to why this acquisition was engaging to us. We can’t be successful with out their distribution community and the robust customer relationships they’ve cast through the years of service and expertise. This can be a channel of which we now have great respect and can do every part we will to help their efforts and progress.”

As for redundancy of merchandise, that shall be determined as soon as the deal formally closes and the companies get deeper into the mixing process, Rodier stated. The same goes for the management roles at CMW and Toro, he stated, noting that Toro has not made a remaining willpower on what the organizational integration will seem like. “But we’ll look to organizationally utilize the deep degree of experience the workforce has together with the channel and buyer experience and relationships, as properly. That stated, we don’t anticipate that there will probably be vital organizational modifications.”

Rodier noted Toro respects the enduring legacy of the Malzahn household and CMW’s contributions within the underground and trenching industries. “These corporations/brands will continue on and be the cornerstones of the underground development enterprise,” he stated. “When it comes to the Charles Machine Works model itself, we now have made no willpower of its future usage.”

“The Toro Co. is a wonderful cultural fit for Charles Machine Works. They’re a well-established, well-run, family-oriented company. They have a superb monitor document of supporting their individuals and the communities the place they function,” Johnson stated. “Please know that the choice to sell did not come straightforward. It’s been a gut-wrenching and tedious course of, but one full of careful consideration for your complete household of corporations and all stakeholders. The financial choice is fairly simple. The emotional choice continues to be past troublesome.”

Sharon M. Bueno is managing editor of Trenchless Know-how.